Reading Time: 5 min read

Charlie Puth, Nine Track Mind © Artist Partner Group/Atlantic

9. Charlie Puth, Nine Track Mind

[Artist Partner Group/Atlantic] 

Metascore: 37

Keeping it real, critics weren’t a fan of Puth’s debut album.  The highest score, a 60 (The Guardian) is respectable, yet average at best.  The worst score came courtesy of Q Magazine – a 25.  Q was just downright mean: Nine Track Mind whimpers like a sick kitten.  To quote Magic! “Why you gotta be so rude?”

We weren’t too kind to Mr. Puth on Starpulse ourselves – he received two-and-half-stars…


the musical hype

the musical hype (Brent Faulkner) has earned Bachelor's and Master's degrees in music (music education, music theory/composition respectively). A multi-instrumentalist, he plays piano, trombone, and organ among numerous other instruments. He's a certified music educator, composer, and freelance music blogger. Faulkner cites music and writing as two of the most important parts of his life. Notably, he's blessed with a great ear, possessing perfect pitch.