Richard Harris, MacArthur Park → The Flops

In the 19th edition of The Flops (2026), we examine the questionable and polarizing “MacArthur Park,” by Richard Harris.

Reading Time: 3 min read

Richard Harris, MacArthur Park: The Flops No. 19 (2026) [📷: Brent Faulkner / The Musical Hype; UMG Recordings, Inc.; Will Oliveira from Pexels; Gordon Johnson, OpenClipart-Vectors from Pixabay]In the 19th edition of The Flops (2026), we examine the questionable and polarizing “MacArthur Park,” by Richard Harris. 

“I know you f***ing lying!” Like damn, bruh! Sis! C’mon! You thought it was bound to hit, but instead it was total shit – nothing but dookie 💩!  The songs that appear in The Flops didn’t hit, underperformed, or underwhelmed.  Flops are even more detrimental when the artist is considered a superstar and rarely misses the mark. Flops can even be successful, even if the quality sucked. Or maybe they’re not-so-bad, but they bombed on the charts.  This column highlights abject failure. In the 19th edition of The Flops (2026), we examine the questionable “MacArthur Park,” recorded by Richard Harris.

“Someone left the cake out in the rain.” Cake in the rain? Huh? What in the world are you talking about, Richard Harris (1930 – 2002)? The Irish actor and singer adds in the chorus of “MacArthur Park,” “I don’t think that I can take it / ‘Cause it took so long to bake it / And I’ll never have that recipe again, oh, no.” ‘Oh, no,’ indeed – that is by far the most polarizing lyric from the ‘hit.’ As ‘unconventional’ as the song was, it reached number two on the Billboard Hot 100 👀. “MacArthur Park” is the sixth track from Harris’ 1968 album, A Tramp Shining. In its full-length form, it runs seven-and-a-half minutes.  In its edited form, Harris still gives us more than five-and-a-half minutes. Songwriter Hall of Famer Jimmy Webb (b. 1946) wrote and produced it.

 

Richard Harris, A Tramp Shining [📷: UMG Recordings, Inc.]“MacArthur Park” is an impressive ‘flop,’ if you consider it a flop at all. The art/Baroque pop backdrop is striking; never dull. That harpsichord, performed by Jimmy Webb, goes a long way, I suppose. The harmonic progression is advanced and adventurous. The orchestration is gnarly. It is quite distinct and unusual.  Richard Harris shows off his beautiful voice. There is never a doubt that the Irish man can sing. But it’s not an edgy or gritty performance – not hard-rocking or soulful. Regardless, he captures the drama of the heartfelt, often surreal, weird lyrics and metaphors: “Spring was never waiting for us, girl / It ran one step ahead / As we followed in the dance.” In the second verse, Harris sings, “I recall the yellow cotton dress / Foaming like a wave / On the ground around your knees.” Poetic, but also a wee bit melodramatic? The bridge is ‘a lot,’ too.

“I will take my life into my hands

And I will use it

I will win the worship in their eyes

And I will lose it

… And after all the loves of my life

Oh, after all the loves in my life

I’ll be thinking of you

And wondering why.”

Heartbreak is the modus operandi. A relationship has gone south.  After the bridge, a quick instrumental section arrives.  Like many moments from the song, it is odd and unexpected.  It keeps the same energy as this unpredictable piece. So, is “MacArthur Park” truly a flop? It depends on personal preference. The musicianship is high-flying, particularly the orchestrations and melodies.  Harris has a beautiful voice and some fine moments.  BUT there is a lot for the ear to take in.  The performance is ‘too much.’ It’s overblown, theatrical, and over the top. And that melting cake in the rain metaphor is quite wild. For me, it’s hard to know what to make of it.  There are more definitive flops, but I understand why folks are critical. Notably, Donna Summer’s (1948 – 2012) Grammy-nominated disco cover reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100.

 


Richard Harris → A Tramp Shining → UMG Recordings, Inc. → 1968
Richard Harris, MacArthur Park: The Flops No. 19 (2026) [📷: Brent Faulkner / The Musical Hype; UMG Recordings, Inc.; Will Oliveira from Pexels; Gordon Johnson, OpenClipart-Vectors from Pixabay]

 

the musical hype
the musical hype

The Musical Hype (he/him) has earned Bachelor's and Master's degrees in music (music education and music theory/composition, respectively). A multi-instrumentalist, he plays piano, trombone, and organ among numerous other instruments. He's a certified music educator, composer, and freelance music blogger. Music and writing are two of the most important parts of his life.

Articles: 11172

Leave a Reply